Seth Godin on Higher Education
Seth shares a few of this thoughts on higher education, this time focusing on undergraduate programs:
There’s no question that a Harvard degree helps (or is even required) in a few fields. There’s also no doubt that spending four years at Yale is a mind-changing experience. The question isn’t, “are they wonderful?” The question is, “Is it worth it?”
It’s almost as if every single high school student and her parents insisted on having a $200,000 stereo because it was better than the $1,000 stereo. Sure, it might be a bit better, but is it better enough?
For most people, the answer is a resounding no. Not only is college expensive, the opportunity costs of college programs are massive. You can accomplish a lot in four years.
My advice for those preparing for undergraduate programs is:
- Focus on getting into a good but inexpensive school in a broad high-value field (business, hard science, math, or engineering).
- Get as many scholarships as you can to defray costs.
- Work a part-time job to pay for living expenses instead of taking out loans.
- Participate in co-op and paid internship programs that have a record of hiring participants full-time after graduation.
- Graduate as quickly as possible.
Outside of the people you meet, the primary value of college is the credential, so the best strategy is to optimize on cost and speed. After you graduate, focus your time and energy on doing real work and invest in increasing your knowledge and skills in areas you find interesting.
Real-world results will always trump college activities when it comes to getting a job or starting your own business.
If you're new to the Personal MBA, you'll want to check out the manifesto and recommended reading list to see what we're all about.
Also, be sure to become a PMBA Insider (it's free), as well as subscribe to the RSS feed to be notified when new posts are published. Thanks for visiting!
3 Comments, Comment or Ping
Grant Czerepak
I spent seven years getting my undergraduate degree. The reason for this is I was earning my way through university by working for the federal government designing and developing computer systems and teaching computing, English and geographic information systems to honors students at the university itself. I learned more working at these jobs than I did earning my piece of paper from my alma mater.
My advice is as soon as possible get a job that complements the discipline you are pursuing for your undergraduate studies. That’s where the real learning takes place.
Nov 2nd, 2007
Gannon Beck
Hey Josh,
I don’t think college is a waste of time, but I do think it makes sense in certain situations and not in others. I wrote an essay about it that explains my thoughts on it here:
http://gannonbeck.com/2007/04/07/to-degree-or-not-to-degree-that-is-the-question
I can’t fathom a situation (for me or anyone I’ve ever met) where it makes sense to pay Harvard prices.
By the way, I had another idea/question, that I’ll send you offlline.
Gannon
Nov 2nd, 2007
Shama Hyder
I finished undergrad in 5 semesters and have always looked back on it as a very smart decision. Optimizing my time saved me a lot of money. I am grateful that I never took student loans. Great post!
Nov 2nd, 2007